Removable battery
(Topic created on:
22/08/2017 04:09 PM
)
20500 Views
Jbeattie
Apprentice
last edited
22/08/2017 04:09 PM
I have lots of money but refuse to buy a smartphone without a removable battery.
The justifications I've heard border on the ridiculous such as the batteries are non-removable to keep the phone slim. Another ridiculous comeback is the "fast charge" reason. Frankly, there are times when I need to go from 5% battery to 100% in an instant and removable battery is the only way to achieve that end. Having two phones also isnt an option because certain apps cannot have the same user account on more than one phone.
The cynic in me tells me there is a more sinister reason for non-removable batteries, but I'll keep the conspiracy theories for another forum.
Now my Note 4, with its Snapdragon 805, is beggining to slow down.
The question is, will I be stuck with a Note 4 until the end of time because Samsung force non-removable battery smartphones on us?
Here's an idea, why doesn't Samsung take a poll to see how many of its customers want removable batteries? Or better still, release both removable and non-removable units and see what the market wants.
Is it really about the wants of the market or are people just obedient consumers? I'd like to think there is hope.
And dont tell me about the LG with its removable battery, I'm just not interested.
BandOfBrothers
MegaStar
last edited
22/08/2017 06:50 PM
I'm not sure where disposable income comes into the equation here @Jbeattie
My thoughts are that the ip86 water resistance comes into play too with non removable batteries.
In my opinion these batteries even though their capacities reduce over time can and will last a good few years.
I prefer not to use Fast Charging if i can help it as imo this can cause extra wear and tear on the battery.
I agree that phones with removable batteries have their Plus points and possibly less cost to buy a new battery than having to employ an engineer to replace one in a sealed phone.
Other such as power banks and battery cases can help.
0 likes
Mdel326
Apprentice
28/02/2018 08:00 PM
I saw the way the industry was going and I went from the Galaxy S4 to the LG G5. Which has a removable battery and has been generally good with a few quirks. If I can I will try to use this phone until 5G is rolled out nationwide. There are no new flagship phones being made with removable batteries these days. Any phone that has a removable battery is limited in both features, lower screen resolution or lower megapixel camera. They can say they make one but you will not want it because the camera will not be good or it won't be able to play the latest games etc. It is really planned obsolesence at its worst and I would prefer to buy an older flagship on ebay than a new removable battery phone that has been purposely downgraded to make it less appealling.
DS56
First Poster
3/04/2018 02:53 PM
I bought 2 new Motorola Turbo Droid 2's a year and a half ago....non replaceable batteries of course and I'm already having problems with mine just a year into using it...tried all the support options and hasn't helped. I'm going back to a Samsung galaxay phone with a replaceable battery. I'm on the go with a special needs child and I have to make sure I have a working phone ready anytime.
Vdub12
Apprentice
3/04/2018 03:02 PM
Ultimately that's the only reason why a manufacturer would get rid of the removable battery . I'm still using a Note 4 because I can replace the battery. The manufacturers want the phones to last less time so they can sell more phones .The fact that I've had to replace the battery 3 times in my Note 4 tells me that I will never use a phone without a removable battery . The cell phone batteries don't last more than a year and in that time you're typically still paying for the phone .
Jukebox75
First Poster
last edited
24/08/2017 11:12 PM
Couldn't agree more. I have my s5 still. It's an awesome phone but it's getting slow and a bit under powered.
It has most needed features and sometimes more than I need. It's not ip68 water proof, but ip67 is more than enough for me. I have a couple of batteries and can change one out at anytime.
I work in the woods. When a battery dies it's not oh I'll just plug it in. I can just change a battery with ease.
I would love a new flagship phone but can't bring myself to spend that kind of money on a phone that I don't like and doesn't work for me.
DRUIDDOODE
Voyager
25/08/2017 08:47 AM
Hi if your still happy to use your s5 it may be worth getting a new battery and having it flashed by an approved repairer
I've seen this mentioned a few times to speed up slow devices to get rid of all the junk that slows them down over time
I did like the S5 although after having the S7 edge the design is a bit stale now.
I must admit I didn't look after my S5 very well but it still worked when I sold it a few months back
Just wish I would of read about the re flash before I sold it as it would of been great to still have a decent back up device
bua
First Poster
last edited
22/01/2018 10:31 AM
I agree with you 100%. What's the point of spending so much money on something that will only last a few years. I used to have a samsung galaxy s4 of which I felt does wonderful job for me. The camera was good enough, the startup time was quick, the OS responsive , and the size was perfect. I accidentally bought an external battery charger and another battery, and was too lazy to return it. That's when I realized how powerful it was having a second battery ready in your pocket. In canada, batteries died very quickly because of the cold. my friend's iphone all had those troubles while I enjoyed extended battery life because of the extra battery. It was super helpful. I only replaced it because the screen was broken beyond repairs.
Nexus 5x was my next phone but it's only been 2 years and already, the battery is dying within 4 hours with the same usage. It's annoying because I'm not always in the office or somewhere that would let me recharge the phone. Charging while using doesnt seem to be doind good either because the phone gets overheated. Charging it for 3 hours brings it up about 20%. I really miss the flexibility that comes with the replaceable battery of galaxy s4. Now what can I do other than tossing it out and buying a new one when the only problem is just the battery. Everything else is still greaat. Why waste so much for a wasted battery.
Also, trust me, having non-replaceable battery doesnt always equal waterproofed phone. My old nexus5 died after being submerged in water. Actually, I could have save it in time as not that much damage has been done but for the life of me I couldn't figure out how to open this seemingly sealed tight case as it was not meant to be opened. Putting the phone in rice obviously werent helping. In the end, it died from being overheated. Waterproofing is not the excuse for having non replaceable battery
casbat21
Student
20/09/2018 05:44 PM
casbat21
Student
20/09/2018 06:01 PM
I had a note 1, then a note 3 ,then a note 4. I love the note series, (but not the ones with no removabable battery. I am hoping the note 10 will have a battery thats removable) I dont care a bout thinness or beveled edges as I put an otter box protective cover over my phone anyway. When I go hiking the ability to carry spare battieries for map purposes and etc is a must. The spare batteries do not take up much space. It takes a minute to change batteries.
So if Samsung is going to keep going this way, they lost a customer as I will buy elsewhere when my phone dies out. ITs just plain corporate greed in action by selling phones with no removable battery.
0 likes
AL50
Journeyman
20/09/2018 06:17 PM
i still use NOTE 4 Not only that I bought few new ones for standby just incase but still on same first phone. never disappointed me so far. its almost perfect phone . slim .good design and its battery replaceable means can carry multiple battery charges at once and carry it. remove them at will .
I think samsung def. need to bring back this feature or min cartridge type release mech like hand guns. through limited slit like opening etc. may be many creative way to address this. Note 9 already has fire on battery . only way when phone gets too hot is to watch them burn. you just dont have enough time to unscrew dissect the phone and remove the battery . Note 4 takes second to dump out hot battery and save the phone. I have already done once from defective battery.
Trinimark
First Poster
last edited
28/01/2018 01:03 AM
This manufacturer is going the way many others including car manufacturers are; and that is to make you pay for much more than you need to in order to keep their profit margins getting fatter and fatter. Generally the battery is the first component in a smartphone to wear out, so now instead of being able to replace your battery for a few dollars and breathe a few more years of life into your phone, you have to buy a whole new phone. Recently my Galaxy S3 that I've had since 2013 started misbehaving. I changed the battery and that solved the problem. If having a phone with a removable battery means switching brands then so be it; because I'm not one to remain loyal to a brand that is out to be unfair to its customers. Not to mention the huge environmental impact and waste of materials resulting from having to throw away an otherwise good phone just because the battery alone is worn out.
Maylene
First Poster
last edited
6/02/2018 12:24 PM
Jbeattie, I am 100% behind what you said. The S series and Note series are almost identical now. They are always supposed to be different: Note series for business and S series for everyday consumer.
Samsung only needs to release 1 model with a removable battery phone to see what the sales are like. I bet it will be much higher than they expect.
I started with the Samsung Note 1 and now, I am holding onto my Note 4 for dear life. The Note 4 being the last model with a removable battery. Business people and travelers really need to be able to flip in a fresh battery and keep on going.
I'm not sure why water resistance is such an important feature. I don't use my phone in the rain, in the bath or on the beach.
Vdub12
Apprentice
last edited
7/03/2018 05:27 AM
I'm also still using a note4 because of the removable battery. If they don't release one with a removable battery soon I plan to buy another note4 with a few less hours on it. As some point I will be forced to move to a different brand. I will not use a phone without a removable battery .I have had to replace my battery 3 times in my note 4 because they only last about a year before the phone starts rebooting when you take a picture. I will not get stuck having to buy a new $1000 phone every year. Not going to happen. Batteries die and they need to be easily replaced .
DrSlump1
Explorer
last edited
7/04/2018 07:39 AM
Hi,
i got a Note 3 since 2013 and i'm still happy with it. Yes, it feels slower than new phones but it does what it must do for my daily needings.
I would like to try the new Note 8 but, in my heavy working day, the plus value that my removable battery gives to me is really important: in less than 10 seconds i'm on the job again, without the needing of an external battery or a "supercharger" or any other technical workarounds.
I've changed 3 batteries over these years (all three genuine samsung batteries), every night i put my phone on charge, no matter the battery level is, becouse i know that if i damage the battery i can easely exchange it with a fresh one with few bucks and in few seconds.
If a Note 8 battery dies i must return the phone for 1 or more days and i must eventually take care about some files that are on the phone removing them or making a backup of them. That's a pain in the ass, only becouse a poor Samsung enginering decision.
So i'm really jealous about my Note 3, and i take care of it so that it can still work for me until this crazy (greedy) behaviour of phone producers will change in a more convenient way for me.
Aric
Student
28/04/2018 01:59 AM
I agree. They need to atleast make the note series a removable battery or release two versions of the phone one with removable and one without. I would buy that note phone in a heartbeat. Samsung this needs to happen for the note 10 and sales will sky rocket! I know so many people who would upgrade their phones and even switch companies for a removable battery.
Vdub12
Apprentice
28/04/2018 02:06 AM
The reason they're not putting removable batteries in phones is because it's planned failure. Since batteries don't last more than a year or 2 they force people to buy new phones more often. So any drop of sales is made up for by people having to buy more phones.
Aric
Student
28/04/2018 02:30 AM
I understand. It just kind of sucks. It's nice to have an option of just popping a fresh battery in and having good battery life or even putting a big battery in and having insane battery life for days. Like the note 4, putting 10,000 mah battery in phone. Instead of getting one of the battery cases just have the battery be internal si it's on one charge preserving the batteries life span
AL50
Journeyman
last edited
11/08/2018 09:05 PM
WE all know WHY samsung followed apple like slave and decided to drop open back plate feature.
its all about MONEY. PROFIT. not having user able to replace battery esp users who imporperly charges battery by making life short, thereby END UP bring the phone in for PAY PER service to have battery replaced or END UP buying a new phone. THAT is the goal and just about EVERYONE knows this. REMOVABLE battery make much greater sense yes. dont tell me it limits the design of phone or water resistance. thats nonsense. we can make phone water resistant (no phone is water proof) With out having it sealed. good example is look at the watches. (you can still change battery yet its 30 m resistant correct? ) thats coming from limited design sense person. I think samsung should remake back plate open and servicable and enable users to put the memory card from back plate and SIM. IT was such user friendly REASON i switched FROM APPLE to samsung first place. I am still stuck with NOTE 4 for that reason. I REFUSE TO BUY another samsung phone until something revolutionary or move back to apple at this time. NOTE 4 was the BEST samsung phone ever made and its stil very popular in the market people buy it alot trade it alot on ebay etc. takes great photos too. WHY samsung has to follow Apples path I dont understand, but user serviceablity is environmentally makes greater sense. And also enables quickly remove the battery in the case battery overheats or going through airports (certain places) or have multiple battery charged and have in hand for easy swap. also Being able to user service it, Samsung also will prevent lawsuits arising from sealed battery implosion or fire. If I sense battery gets too hot. I would immediatly toss the battery out and save the phone from damages.
its the FEATURE and APPS that makes the phone sell besides the design. I THINK SAMSUNG NEED TO REINTRODUCE OPENABLE BACK PLATE DESIGNS with dual sims, triple sims and more user friendly features. THat itself sets apart from all other brand. I think NOTE 5-8 is the Probably the UGLIST phone ever produced from samsung with curvature design at corner ugly back plate, as far as design is go. LOOK at the NOKIA, or SIEMENS for innovations. they prob are one of the best designers of phones. FOCUS on other aspect of the phone Dont take away the best feature from it. WHY would anyone submerge the phone in the water first place (those are pretty RARE) water proofing tight seal prob made phone to heat up unable to vent the heat causing furthre heat damages. very bad idea. samsung designers WAKE UP I TELL YOU. iwill fire them all if I am the design director.
AL50
Journeyman
14/09/2018 02:49 AM
People are getting smarter by min. We can take the phone apart upgrade troubleshoot replace parts.... hum.. that's what they don't like us to do. Bring the phones in.let me charge customer $125
On top of 1000 phone. They just don't want us to keep the same phone too long !! We all know this.
Gfoster
Student
14/09/2018 03:37 AM
Samsung Galaxy S5. Water proof, slim design not bulky, stop being lazy just plug the phone in to charge it, and oh wait it is very easy to change the battery in
Vdub12
Apprentice
14/09/2018 06:06 AM
Im still using a note 4 because of the removable battery. I have to replace my batteries every year because they go bad. I will not replace a phone because every year because it doesn't have a removable battery. Also I will not buy another Samsung unless they go back to removable batteries. If I am stuck with non removable batteries then I will get a phone that's at least root friendly. I'm thinking the one+.
Icecream
Journeyman
last edited
21/05/2020 03:11 AM
It's nice to know Samsung has made xcover pro with removable battery this year.
However I really hope they make Note 4 2020 version or any mid range A series phones with removable battery.
Imagine if Samsung made like a note 4 / Alpha 2020 version.
It's annoying how excuse is water proof/ slimmer phones. When we know the S5 is waterproof, and the new xcover pro is water proof.
I am not bothered with waterproof phones, or even wireless charging.
I just want a good mid range / flag spec phone like a note 4 updated version with removable battery. Just needed to have a good camera with latest software.
0 likes
AL50
Journeyman
21/05/2020 01:53 PM
wow thanks for update on that news. I am all in for that XcoverPro. 64GB 22.5MP. at f1.7 battery door access. what else do you need. I am buying few of those in time. that is the answer to our prayers. at $499 dollars. I guess they listen move the market fast. smart way to do it. look bit like NOTE 4 Thin.
NOTE 4 is prob the last of its kind. but I still use them & have several back up. I hear people having blackouts , sudden shuts offs. battery drain all those after Upgrade to OS 6. (samsung call it battery efficency I say really? ) many opt NOT to upgrade the OS to 6.0 keep them in OS 5. seem to work better. (try that)
As per the battery it makes no sense samsung charges over 1700 a phone (that is insane amount of money for middle class for example) to obtain not to mention burden of lock up 3 years of payment. (this is to prevent people defect to other brand) about the battery access, they can easily make the battery access (like Gun cartridge with smaller access area) then entire back plate if they prefer not to open up entirely, although I prefer the entire back plate open so that memory and all other can be accessed. its very convenient carry a ready charged batteries in hand for swap esp during travel. (several, in case) like myself many just dont give up on that phone.
One of the best feature of samsung NOTE 4 is in its camera. NOTE 4 came with 16MP camera very bright lense takes gret photos all other cam following it all came with 12 MPs. so I buy them keep it for as camera itself. Hope they release upgrade version of the NOTE 4 . slim nice design. SAMSUNG LEAVE THE BACK COVER ACCESSABLE. DONT BE GREEDY. I say.
0 likes
Icecream
Journeyman
21/05/2020 02:23 PM
Because they haven't had many options I have even been looking at other brands.
Example moto e6 plus has removable battery and if you compare it to Samsung A50 it's very similar when it comes to specs.
I also like what LG has done with all metal phone, it let's you open the back with removable battery it sorts of reminds me of an old metal Nokia.
0 likes
Icecream
Journeyman
29/05/2020 03:38 PM
https://www.sammobile.com/news/is-samsung-bringing-back-removable-batteries-cheap-smartphones/
I'm excited about this, it's about time!
0 likes